Introduction
Tool breakage is one of the most
common and expensive problems faced in CNC machining, mostly during high-speed
milling operations. A broken tool not only means the loss of a costly cutter but
also leads to damage of the workpieces, which in turn increases machine
downtime, missed delivery schedules, and if the situation is difficult, it may
also lead to damage of the tool holder or even the spindle. Therefore, in high-speed
CNC milling, where we expect the cutting speeds, feed rates, and productivity to
be high, at the same time, the risk of failure of the tool increases if
machining parameters and handling of the machine are not properly done.
Reducing tool breakage is
therefore very important for improving productivity, reducing
manufacturing costs, and maintaining stable part quality. Here are the best
practical ways to reduce the tool breakage in high-speed CNC milling.
1. Select the Right Cutting
Tool for the Application
·
With my experience, I found that one of the
primary reasons for tool breakage is using the wrong tool for the job.
High-speed CNC milling requires tools that are specifically designed to
withstand high cutting forces, elevated temperatures, and continuous operation.
·
In most high-speed milling operations, carbide
tools are preferred because they provide high hardness, good wear resistance,
and can withstand higher cutting temperatures compared to conventional tools.
·
I have also found that coated carbide tools give
even better results in high-speed machining. These coatings reduce friction and
protect the cutting edge from excess heat, which significantly improves tool
life during continuous machining.
·
On the other hand, based on practical
observations, HSS tools are not suitable for high-speed milling. Their lower
heat resistance causes rapid edge wear and tool failure when used at high
cutting speeds.
Tool geometry matters
Tool geometry plays a major role
in cutting performance:
- A proper helix angle helps in smooth chip
evacuation.
- Sharp cutting edges reduce cutting force.
- A correct number of flutes give balance between
strength and chip clearance.
For example, using a high-flute tool for deep slot milling can cause chip clogging, leading to tool breakage.
Match the tool to the work
material
Each work material behaves
differently during cutting:
- Aluminium requires sharp tools with polished
flutes.
- Steel needs tougher tools with heat-resistant
coatings.
- Hardened materials require rigid tools with optimised
geometry.
Selecting the correct tool based
on the material is the first and most important step in preventing tool
breakage.
2. Optimise Cutting Parameters
(Speed, Feed, and Depth of Cut)
In real CNC machining practice,
wrong cutting parameters are one of the main reasons for tool breakage. Even a
good-quality tool will fail if the speed, feed, or depth of cut is not set
correctly.
Cutting speed
Running the spindle too fast
increases heat generation at the cutting edge. Excessive heat softens the tool
material, leading to edge chipping and sudden breakage. On the other hand, very
low speed can cause rubbing instead of cutting, which also damages the tool. Always
follow the tool manufacturer’s recommended cutting speed for the specific
material.
Feed rate
An incorrect feed rate can
overload the tool:
- Too high feed rate causes excessive cutting force
and tool deflection.
- Too low feed rate leads to rubbing, heat buildup,
and premature failure.
In practical CNC machining, a correct
feed rate helps in producing proper chips and smooth cutting.
Depth and width of cut
High-speed milling often uses smaller
depths of cut with higher speeds. Taking deep cuts at high speed puts excessive
stress on the tool, especially during entry and exit. Using step-down and step-over strategies
reduces cutting load and significantly improves tool life.
3. Ensure Proper Tool Holding
and Machine Rigidity
Even the best tool and correct parameters cannot prevent breakage if the tool-holding system or machine setup is weak.
Tool holder quality
Poor-quality tool holders cause:
- Runout
- Vibration
- Uneven load on cutting edges
These factors directly increase
the risk of tool breakage. Using precision collets, shrink-fit holders, or
hydraulic holders ensures better grip and alignment.
Tool overhang
A long tool overhang causes more
vibration during cutting. This vibration weakens the cutting edge and can
suddenly break the tool. Always:
- Keep tool overhang as short as possible
- Use longer tools only when absolutely required
Machine rigidity
High-speed milling demands a
rigid machine structure. Loose machine components, worn guideways, or spindle
issues can amplify vibration and shock loads on the tool.
Regular machine maintenance helps
in maintaining rigidity and preventing tool-related failures.
4. Improve Chip Evacuation and
Cooling
Poor chip evacuation is a silent
but serious cause of tool breakage. When chips are not removed properly, they
get re-cut, increasing cutting forces and temperature.
Chip evacuation
High-speed milling produces chips
very quickly. If chips remain in the cutting zone:
- Tool edges chip
- Flutes clog
- Tool snaps suddenly
Using the right flute design and
proper cutting strategy ensures smooth chip flow away from the cutting area.
Coolant application
Coolant plays a major role in:
- Reducing cutting temperature
- Flushing away chips
- Preventing built-up edge formation
Depending on the application:
- Flood coolant is effective for general milling
- High-pressure coolant improves chip evacuation in
deep pockets
- Dry machining may be suitable with coated tools and
proper airflow
In practical CNC machining,
improper or uneven coolant supply can cause thermal shock, which leads to tool
cracking and breakage.
5. Use Proper Tool Path
Strategy and CAM Programming
Modern CNC machining relies
heavily on CAM software, and poor tool path strategies often result in
unnecessary tool breakage.
Smooth tool entry and exit
Sudden plunging or sharp tool
entry increases the impact load on the tool. Using:
- Ramping
- Helical entry
- Gentle lead-in movements
reduces stress and prevents
chipping of cutting edges.
Adaptive and high-efficiency
milling
High-efficiency milling (HEM) or
adaptive tool paths maintain a constant tool load. This:
- Reduces peak cutting forces
- Minimises tool wear
- Increases tool life
Traditional tool paths with
full-width cuts at high speed often overload the tool and cause breakage.
Avoid sudden direction changes
Sharp corners and sudden changes
in direction cause tool deflection and vibration. CAM programs should use
smooth arcs instead of sharp corners wherever possible.
Well-planned tool paths
distribute cutting forces evenly and protect the tool during high-speed
operations.
Conclusion
Based on practical CNC machining
experience, tool breakage in high-speed milling does not happen due to a single
mistake. It is usually caused by a combination of wrong tool selection,
incorrect cutting parameters, poor tool holding, improper chip removal, or
unsuitable tool paths. By following the five methods explained above, CNC
operators can reduce tool breakage and improve machining performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
(FAQs)
1. What is the most common
cause of tool breakage in high-speed CNC milling?
The most common cause of tool
breakage is incorrect cutting parameters, especially excessive feed rate
or depth of cut. When the tool is overloaded, it cannot withstand the cutting
forces and breaks suddenly.
2. Why do carbide tools break
during high-speed milling?
Carbide tools usually break due
to excessive heat, vibration, or poor tool holding. Improper speed
selection, long tool overhang, or poor chip evacuation can cause micro-cracks
that lead to tool failure.
3. How does tool overhang
affect tool life?
Long tool overhang increases tool
deflection and vibration, which weakens the cutting edge. This vibration
can cause chipping and eventually lead to tool breakage, especially during
high-speed operations.
4. Can wrong coolant usage
cause tool breakage?
Yes. Improper coolant application
can cause thermal shock, chip re-cutting, and excessive heat buildup.
Inconsistent or incorrect coolant flow often results in premature tool failure.
5. What role does CAM
programming play in tool breakage?
Poor CAM programming can overload
the tool by using aggressive tool paths, sharp corners, or direct plunging.
Proper tool path strategies, like adaptive milling and smooth entry movements,
help reduce tool stress.
6. Is high-speed milling
possible without tool breakage?
Yes, high-speed milling can be
done safely by using correct tools, optimised cutting parameters, rigid tool
holding, and proper tool paths. Many industries successfully run high-speed
machining with minimal tool failures.
7. How can vibration be
reduced in CNC milling?
Vibration can be reduced by:
- Using high-quality tool holders
- Reducing tool overhang
- Maintaining machine rigidity
8. Does chip evacuation affect
tool breakage?
Poor chip evacuation causes chip
clogging and re-cutting, which increases cutting forces and temperature. Proper
flute design, coolant flow, and tool path selection help in effective chip
removal.
9. Why do tools break suddenly
without warning?
Sudden tool breakage usually
occurs due to hidden micro-cracks, excessive vibration, or overload.
These issues develop gradually but cause instant failure when the tool reaches
its limit.
10. How can tool breakage be
reduced in CNC training workshops?
In training workshops, tool
breakage can be reduced by:
- Teaching correct parameter selection
- Using proper tool holding methods
- Avoiding aggressive cutting
.svg){kind=icon}
Subscribe